rancière disidentification
: 38). We attempt to develop a Rancièrian framework for understanding class identities, centred on his key concept of dissensus, and how these ideas have been developed by Imogen Tyler through the notion of ‘classificatory struggles’. Heidi Salaverría, Ph.D., is a philosopher, lecturer, performance and cultural worker, born in Caracas, living in Hamburg.Studies and research stays in Buenos Aires and Philadelphia. Buy Communities of Sense: Rethinking Aesthetics and Politics by Hinderliter, Beth, Maimon, Vered, Mansoor, Jaleh, McCormick, Seth online on Amazon.ae at best prices. Transformations 19. Post a Review . That is, rather than marking definitive distinctions, a partager marks "a process of subjectivization" as "a process of disidentification or declassification" or a dissensus. Communities of Sense argues for a new understanding of the relation between politics and aesthetics in today’s globalized and image-saturated world. (Plenary) Adorno/ Rancière: Obtuse Reality and the Double Poetics of the Image. Rancière considers an authoritative motto of the July Monarchy (P 264), but ... from transformative processes of disidentification. Disidentification, ... Weaving together Jacques Rancière's writings on... more. You can write a book review and share your experiences. Academia.edu is a place to share and follow research. In these interviews, against the background of informed and beautifully crafted questions, Rancière works through and articulates, forms and re-forms, the words that contour his thought and provide it with its depth and power: equality, speech, subjectivization, stupidity, contradiction, possibility, event, scene, police, aesthetic regime, and on and on. For Rancière, most social and political orders are characterized by what he calls the police. In common with much SEA research, it suppresses politics through a focus on the social or moral dimensions of SEA (e.g. Janice Lee. Politics and its others: Jacques Rancière's figures of alterity Pribiag, I. V., Mar 1 2019, In: Philosophy Today. It involved a process of disidentification, another relation to speech, visibility and so on.11 As these examples indicate, Rancière understands aesthetics in a rather specialized sense. Introduction Palestine as Metaphor. disidentification; it occurs when people are coming together and act ‘as political subjects in the interval or the gap between two identities, neither of which we could assume […] between names, identities, cultures and so on’ (Rancière, 1995, p. 61-62). emphasizing the ‘social contract’ or identifying ideal DISIDENTIFICATION AND THE POSSIBILITY OF EGALITARIAN INSCRIPTION. 12, #2, Autumn 2008 “Jacques Rancière: Literature and Equality,” Philosophy Compass, Vol. Paulo Freire's Last Laugh: Rethinking critical pedagogy's funny bone through Jacques Rancière | Tyson Edward Lewis | download | BookSC. Secondly, this dialectic of identification and disidentification disrupted the equation of the private sphere–concerning feelings, gender and sexuality–with the home, as well as the equation of affect with the absence of reason 12. öncelikle bu tanımın siyasete değil, polise * ait olduğunu söyler. Disidentification, Anticipation and the Aesthetics of the Popular Lecture, 26 October 2011, Ruhr University Bochum, 6 p.m., GABF 04/411 Selected Publications Dasgupta, Sudeep. But the rise of new fields of inquiry, coupled with a growing dissatisfaction within existing fields, have put pressure on the traditional forms through which scholarship is pursued. These spaces are, however, situated in the context of deep DOWNLOAD NOW » Author: Theodor W. Adorno. Matt Lieberman is a senior from Boston studying Journalism, Political Science and Integrated Marketing Communications. Janice Lee is a Korean-American writer, editor, publisher, and shamanic healer. To paraphrase both Rancière and the French litigator, becoming a fugitive involves disidentification and a strategy of rupture. Thesis 8: The essential work of politics is the configuration of its own space. Subjectification, on the other hand, is always “disidentification, removal from the naturalness of a place” (Rancière 1995a, p. 36; see also Ruitenberg 2010a). ’Deltagelse’ står lige nu højt på dagsordenen i det kunst- og kulturvidenskabelige felt. Gabriel Rockhill and Philip This article focuses on Jacques Rancière’s reflections on Alfredo Jaar’s The Rwanda Project in the context of wider discussions of the politics of naming the dead. 63, 2, p. 447-470 24 p. Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review Read this book using Google Play Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices. Politics engages with and in the police order “by rephrasing and restaging social issues, police problems, and so on” (Rancière… In particular, it provides a detailed reading of disidentification and impossible identification as they relate to figures of the Other. For some people on this list, the networked society is making great progress toward co … Rancière, however, focuses on the effects of people acting as if they are equal ... 2012). Senses of Cinema was founded on stolen lands. 14:00 – 14:45 Clémence Saintemarie: “Disidentification or De-differentiation? The ‘process of disidentification’, in other words, is dependent upon a trope ‘that links the name of a group or class to the name of no group or no class, a being to a non-being or a not-yet being’ (Rancière 1992, 61)—dependent, that is to say, upon a necessarily improper metonymic performative. Rancière’s Pragmatics of Resistance” Chair: Professor Maeve Cooke. ... Rancière proposes that politics and staging equality are rare and intermittent moments. It is the political space of what he calls “un-being.” In Rancière’s words, ... of play, a process of disidentification or counteridentity (un-being), which Break. June 2019. The dream becomes political, a contestation of colonial fictions that I call counter-dreaming. 7 Jacques Rancière, The Disagreement, Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press 1998, p. 36. disidentification, a removal from the naturalness of a place, the opening up of a subject space where anyone can be counted since it is the space where those of no account are counted, where a connection is made between having a part and having no part.7 “Construction of Political Subjects: Disidentification in Honneth and Rancière” 3:30-3:45pm . Aesthetic politics: staging the wound Part II 4. At this point I would say some kind of rupture, some kind of break is essential. argues for a new understanding of the relation between politics and aesthetics in today’s globalized and image-saturated world.. Jacques Rancière in order to renew the notions of political subjectivation and disidentification in the context of political struggles. Questioning the process of knowledge construction in a research in Chiapas, Mexico Raúl Cabrera Psicología Social de Grupos e Instituciones – Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana Xochimilco, Mexico Mexico Anika Meckesheimer The Spare Image in an Unsparing World: Framing the Soldier in an Indeterminate War. Rancière questions this logic and articulates a different approach. Biesta proposes a 'systematic reconstruction' of these ideas [not at all like an exposition of course] focusing on political theory, political practice and the practice of education. Established in Melbourne (Australia) in 1999, Senses of Cinema is one of the first online film journals of its kind and has set the standard for professional, high quality film-related content on the Internet. Jan Masschelein - 2010 - Educational Philosophy and Theory 42 (5-6):588-605. Politika bir düzen değil, polisin düzenini kesintiye uğratan, hiyerarşisini parçalayan bir özneleşme sürecidir, yerini bilmeme, kendine biçilen kimlikle özdeşleşmemedir (disidentification). Jan Masschelein Maarten Simons - 2010 - Educational Philosophy and Theory 42 (5-6):588-605. Since the publication of Black Skin, White Masks in 1952, the theoretical basis upon which we understand our socio-political realities has transformed significantly. Politics and Aesthetics: With and Around Jacques Rancière, University of Amsterdam, June 2006. Genet and commitment: politics and aesthetics 2. Rancière theorizes a practice of self-fashioning that involves a rejection of one's socially fixed identity. Stefan Apostolou-Hölscher (Giessen): "To subjectivize oneself in order to get rid of identity: Jacques Rancière's thinking of disidentification" Panel 8: Contested Collective Identities. ISBN: 978-1472508218. A hypothetical “Algerian history of French philosophy” elicits a variegated but in many ways opaque picture. Abstract. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read Marshall Plan Modernism: Italian Postwar Abstraction and the Beginnings of Autonomia. And that moment of dis-identification is all too rare. 2011. North West University Potchefstroom, Philosophy, Postdoctoral Research Fellow This community has been created through a disidentification which, according to Rancière, is characterized by dissensus. “Disidentification” is an idea that has come to be associated with the thought of Jacques Rancière. ISBN: 978-1472508218. Review published in Symposium: The Canadian Journal of Continental Philosophy July 2016 Matthew R. McLennan Devin Zane Shaw’s Egalitarian Moments situates, defends, and operationalizes the work of Jacques Rancière by linking it to “an egalitarian … Devin Zane Shaw, Egalitarian Moments: From Descartes to Rancière. Type: Tese: Title: Política das ruas e das redes : autoexposição e anonimato nas multidões de Junho de 2013: Authors: Márcia Maria da Cruz: First Advisor: Ricardo Fabrino Men 3:45-5:15pm . Our contention is that not all forms of disagreement, disidentification and classificatory struggle signify active and progressive resistance to the neoliberal production of class names. Here is the conundrum. Governmental, Political and Pedagogic Subjectivation: Foucault with Rancière. By Saikeerthi Rachavelpula Originally published in the 2019 print edition. This dialogue seeks to confront and intertwine the conceptual logics of Hannah Arendt and Jacques Rancière in order to renew the notions of political subjectivation and disidentification in the context of political struggles. ”A process of subjectivation is thus a process of disidentification or declassification. Final Thesis Dissertation for the Master's Degree in Political Philosophy, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona. ranciere, gerçek hayatta kullandığımız bir çok kelimeyi yapısöküme uğratır ve altında yatanları ortaya çıkarır. The Politics of Disidentification Airi Triisberg. and disidentification: Rancière and the Black Consciousness Movement First submission: 19 February 2020 Acceptance: 6 October 2020 Published: 31 December 2020 This article addresses the contentious issue of the relation between emancipatory politics and identity-based forms of politics, especially in a colonialist context. Jacques Rancière conducted a critique of both instances in an attempt to bring about the third one, which is based on equality. Transnational … Maria Muhle is professor for Philosophy | Aesthetic Theory at the Academy of Fine Arts Munich and founder of the August Verlag Berlin. Although Rancière does not pay much specific attention to law—and there is a strong temptation to identify law with what he terms the "police order"—much of For him, ‘subjectification’ is a ‘disidentification’, a willed ‘removal’ from the ‘naturalness of a place’ and the shedding of the identity which one has being given (Rancière, 1999, p. 36). Content: Established forms of scholarly inquiry often appear immutable. Rancière highlights the tangled nature of police-politics relations – he rejects the idea of a ‘pure’ politics operating in its own space. List of figures Acknowledgements Part I Introduction 1. Jacques Rancière’s Figures of Alterity. Disidentification, anxiety and narration as epistemological windows. Indeed, there is much in Hamilton’s account of the politics of aesthetic representation and contending groups that overlaps with the forms of “disidentification,” invoking of new identities, resisting social conventions, and affirmation of conflict over consensus that characterizes Rancière’s account of politics. Disidentification is by no means a smooth, even or easy process, illustrated by the health and family problems experienced by many PAH members. Introduction “As the postcolonial… model of global authority takes shape and reconfigures relationships between the overdeveloped, the developing, and the developmentally arrested worlds, it is important to ask what critical perspectives might nurture the … Etienne Tassin, Université Paris Diderot, Sciences sociales Department, Faculty Member. April 2020 Project: Rancière, Radical Politics and Aesthetics, and the Decolonial Disquieted by the bulging eyes and gaping mouths of Swaihwe masks, Lévi-Strauss saw mythological representations not as isolated objects, but as aesthetic planes for the axes of life and death, cosmology and humanity, estrangement and belonging.1 A similar sentiment is cast by the masked individuals… 3, #1, 2008 “Deleuze and the Tale of Two Intifadas,” in Deleuzian Encounters: Studies in Contemporary Social Issues, ed. Jean-Philippe Deranty, Acumen Press, 2010 “Rancière in South Carolina,” Jacques Rancière: History, Politics, Aesthetics, ed. This dissertation situates current Chinese international students in the historical flow of internationally mobile Chinese people since the late 19th century. Elaborating upon the possibility of a Emancipatory Politics Between Identity and Disidentification: Rancière and the Black Consciousness Movement more by Matthias Pauwels This article addresses the contentious issue of the relation between emancipatory politics and identity- based forms of politics, especially in a colonialist context. Disidentification, anxiety and narration as epistemological windows. Rancière is literally “un-qualified” to speak about this topic and yet this un-qualification is the perfect qualification. Rancière's own insistence is thus to show how every division is also a "partage du sensible" — at once a dividing and a sharing of the in-between. Studies Literature, Critical Theory, and Poetry. 0 comments . Fast and free shipping free returns cash on delivery available on eligible purchase. Current radical democratic politics is characterized by new participatory spaces for citizens' engagement, which aim at facilitating the democratic ideals of freedom and equality. In fact, that's exactly why Rancière says that politics is rare. Our age abounds with feminist, gay, black, and other identity-based aesthetics. Aesthetics as sensory experience harbours the potential for triggering multiple forms of displacement - in subjective experience, the different fields of art, and across disciplines. Download books for free. In the second section, contributors investigate how sense was constructed in the past by the European avant-garde and how it … Jacques Rancière: Education, Truth, Emancipation | Charles Bingham, Jacques Rancière, Gert Biesta | download | Z-Library. Neil Levi offers a critical perspective on this politics of identification with the figure of the Jew that is consonant with my own stress on implicated subjects. Here a new essay by Rancière posits art as a key site where disagreement can be staged in order to produce new communities of sense. Studies Philosophy, Political Philosophy, and Political Economy. Devin Zane Shaw, Egalitarian Moments: From Descartes to Rancière.London: Bloomsbury Academic, 2016; 224 pages. Tracing the shift: the event of the wound 3. He wrote this research paper during Northwestern’s Art, Literature & Contemporary European Thought (ALCET) program in Paris, France. Excentric Interiority and the Politics of the Neutral: Wildside, Barthes and Rancière. 14:45 – 15:00 BREAK. He defines the police in terms that are, as he notes, usually reserved for politics. In 20 th century philosophy, there are numerous theories, which cover the question of (political) subjectivisation or, generally speaking, the process in which an individual becomes a (political) subject. Jacques Rancière and Time: le temps d'après Jacques Rancière and Time: le temps d'après Robson, Mark; 2015-11-01 00:00:00 This article asks whether the work of Jacques Rancière might be said to present a philosophy of time. Chair: Silke Schmidt. Exploding the bordello in The Balcony: spectacle, allegory and the wound of theatre 5. Marshall Plan Modernism: Italian Postwar Abstraction and the Beginnings of Autonomia - Ebook written by Jaleh Mansoor. Contemporary Art and the Politics of Aesthetics / Jacques Rancière 31 The Romantic Art Work / Alexander Potts 51 From Classical to Postclassical Beauty: Institutional Critique and Aesthetic Enigma in Louise Lawler's Photography / Toni Ross 79 Technologies of Belonging: Sensus Communis, Disidentification / Ranjana Khanna 111 Part Two. Rancière’s Notion of Radical Politics and Assertions of Black Identity in South Africa. Modes of contestation in revolutionary Iran resulted from situational parallels with the afterlives of “May ’68”—the event and historical period that inspired Rancière… Find books Anders Fjeld, Université Paris 7- Diderot, Laboratoire du Changement Social et Politique, Graduate Student. Rancière kitap boyunca örtük olarak, sonradan yazmış olduğu sonsözde ise açıkça, şunu savunur: Yoksullar ancak bu sözde işbölümünü (yazarın deyimiyle "duyulur olanın bu bölüşümü"nü) reddettikleri, yani tam da hadlerini aşıp düşünme konusunda da eşitlik talep ettikleri sürece siyasal bir … Rancière, by contrast, offers little systematic justification for his assumption that the politics of emancipation must or should always proceed by means of disidentification and disassociation. Reviewed by Matthew R. McLennan, Saint Paul University Devin Zane Shaw’s Egalitarian Moments situates, defends, and operationalizes the work of Jacques Rancière by linking it to “an egalitarian concept of subjectivity” distilled from Descartes. His aim is not the construction of an alternative collective identity but disidentification and the manifestation of the equality underlying every social relation. Ethics, Politics and the Visuality of the Other Migratory Aesthetics Conference, ASCA … 6: The Art of Taking Part sætter fokus på deltagelse i museet. I think that Thesis 7 (the police) and Thesis 8 (politics) are sibling commentaries on the spacio-legal order so I have paired them here. 2005:288). Dasgupta, Sudeep. Aesthetics as sensory experience harbours the potential for triggering multiple forms of displacement - in subjective experience, the different fields of art, and across disciplines. In particular, it provides a detailed reading of disidentification and impossible identification as they relate to figures of the Other. Jacques Rancière, Disagreement: Politics and Philosophy (1995). Departing from such approaches, Rancière defines the twin notion of declassification and disidentification as processes by which individuals abandon their predetermined social role, enabling them to take up the cause of another (Rancière 1998:212, 219-20, Blechman et al. by Rancière, with ‘disidentification’, an authentic politics only arising when 2Peter Brooks (1976)The Melodramatic Imagination: Balzac, Henry James, Melodrama and … Drehli Robnik is historian and film theorist based in Vienna-Erdberg with a PhD in film studies from University of Amsterdam. The ‘process of disidentification’, in other words, is dependent upon a trope ‘that links the name of a group or class to the name of no group or no class, a being to a non-being or a not-yet being’ (Rancière 1992, 61)—dependent, that is to say, upon a necessarily improper metonymic performative. That is why, for Rancière, political subjectivization is always also a process of disidentification – a disidentification of parts of society from themselves and from the places they occupy. It is not for him, as one might expect, the field of research known as the philosophy of art, even though his work is replete with consequences for such pursuits. Jacques Rancière | Staging the People The Proletarian and His Double PDF These essays from the 1970s mark the inception of the distinctive project that Jacques Rancière has pursued across forty years, with four interwoven themes: the study of working-class identity, of its philosophical interpretation, of "heretical" knowledge and of the relationship between work… Appropriation and disidentification. London: Bloomsbury Academic, 2016; 224 pages. Traditional political philosophy, however, is ill‐equipped in this regard, as Rancière argues. Questioning the process of knowledge construction in a research in Chiapas, Mexico Raúl Cabrera Psicología Social de Grupos e Instituciones – Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana Xochimilco, Mexico Mexico Anika Meckesheimer Although relatively unknown a decade ago, the work of the French philosopher Jacques Rancière is fast becoming a central reference in the humanities and social sciences. Jacques Rancière reveals its intrinsic link to politics by analysing what they both have in common: the delimitation of the visible and the invisible, the audible and the inaudible, the thinkable and the unthinkable, the possible and the impossible. As Rancière sees it, it is incumbent on us to think of political alternatives and confront the post‐democratic liaison between neoliberalism and right‐wing extremism. Rancière sees genuine art and politics as those that create new relations between the visible and the invisible, liberating bodies from their assigned places and breaking with the ‘natural’ order of the sensible. No Marketing Blurb. Publisher: Verso Books ISBN: 1844676641 Category: Philosophy Page: 246 View: 409 An intense and lively debate on literature and art between thinkers who became some of the great figures of twentieth-century philosophy and literature The ‘process of disidentification’, in other words, is dependent upon a trope ‘that links the name of a group or class to the name of no group or no class, a being to a non-being or a not-yet being’ (Rancière 1992, 61)—dependent, that is to say, upon a necessarily improper metonymic performative. For Rancière, equality has a performative, almost tautological character – it "exists to the extent that some subject acts and speaks on the assumption that equality exists" (Barbour 2010: 254-255). The two voices agree to discuss converging and diverging Find books Gallery Rent Model: Owner-Tenant Relations in Exhibiting Minna L. Henriksson. 6 6 “From Universality to Equality: Badiou’s Critique of Rancière” (co-authored with Jeff Love), Symposium, Vol. Processes of disidentification lead to the formation of political subjects who claim identities at odds with those defined by the social categories to which they belong—according to the police order (ibid. To paraphrase both Rancière and the French litigator, becoming a fugitive involves disidentification and a strategy of rupture. Plenary: Katerina Kolozova. A. Hickey-Moody and P. Matins. Communities of Sense. 15:00 – 15:45 Benjamin Modarres: “The Social Dimensions of the Critique of Judgment” Platon’un “polis”i Rancière’in politika kavrayışının tam karşısında yer alır. In other words, Jacques Rancière and Time: le temps d'après Jacques Rancière and Time: le temps d'après Robson, Mark; 2015-11-01 00:00:00 This article asks whether the work of Jacques Rancière might be said to present a philosophy of time. 8, Acumen Press, 2010 “Politics: Radical Democracy,” Jacques Rancière: Key Concepts, ed. In a sense, the whole matter of my paper is involved in a preliminary question: In what language will it be uttered? Alex Lenoble, University of South Florida, World Languages Department, Faculty Member. Precarious Sociality reveals an arc from the dissolution of class narratives of 20 th-century militant cinema to the full recognition of difference and disidentification—a necessary reckoning that allows for new solidarity grounded in precariousness. Jacques Rancière opposes a type of politics that makes decisions on the people, for the people, instead of the people; a politics that holds that in the political order, all sections of the community have been assigned their proper place. It will invoke Rancière’s conception of the disagreement or polemic as a way to assess the radicalism of a radical break, Žižek’s use of Leninism to think about the disruption of consensus, and Derrida’s account of the promise and the event as a core component of the peculiar realism of demanding the impossible. Jacques Rancière: heterology, disidentification and equality 74 A community of interruptions without a common identity 78 The subject and/as politics: the redistribution of the sensible 79 “The staging of a common place”: Rancière and the theatre 81 Conclusion 83 Disidentification, ... Weaving together Jacques Rancière's writings on... more. This leads to a second problem. of resistance.6 Rancière speaks in consonance with this, saying that subjectification is the production of a capacity to enunciate, not previously identifiable, in a given field of experience,7 hence the fact that subjectification always implies a change, or, as Rancière says, a disidentification that inaugurates a new subject space, a different "Politics [...] is that activity which turns on equality as its principle", and begins when inequality is challenged. As Rancière asserts, “Politics is about ‘wrong’ names—misnomers that articulate a gap and connect with a wrong” (62). Communities of Sense argues for a new understanding of the relation between politics and aesthetics in today’s globalized and image-saturated world. The premise of equality is deeply rooted in Rancière’s philosophy . Acting out of the communist hypothesis means changing one's Postcolonial Studies, Jacques Rancière, David Harvey, Henri Lefebvre, Solidarity, and 7 more Right to the city, Disidentification, Saul Alinsky, Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, urban struggles, De … Among the chorus of chants and slogans echoing from Tunisia to Egypt, Syria, and beyond starting in late 2010, popular expressions of support for Palestine have been a remarkably persistent leitmotiv. This article revises Rancière’s account of political subjectivation by taking into account the social conditions that … Recording Reality, Desiring the Real analyses documentary media through the lens of psychoanalytic, deconstructionist and semiotic theory. For example, Rancière’s notion of disidentification, which is the refusal to take up allocated social positions, is useful for researching learning in and through everyday workplace practices (Harman, 2017b). Renegotiating the terrain of the dream-image, as it is conceptualized by Gilles Deleuze in Cinema 2, this article examines how Barnaby’s Rhymes for Young Ghouls troubles discourses of reconciliation through the circulation of unreconciled images. Whereas ‘Le sociologue roi’ had concentrated on a critique of La reproduction (Bourdieu & Passeron, 1970) and La distinction (Bourdieu, 1979), treating them as objectivist Download books for free. siyaset bilimcilerin, toplumu düzenleyen ve bir arada durmasını sağlayan kurumlar ve pratikler bütünü olarak tanımladıkları siyaseti çok farklı alır. Subjectification “inscribes a subject name as being different from any identified part of the community” (ibid., p. 37). Treating others equally is a deeply political action, as Jacques Rancière has carefully documented, but it is also the sign of a desire to treat them well, to be preoccupied by others and by my relation to them. Rancière’s work has received wide and increasing critical attention, but no study exists so far that reflects on the wider implications of Rancière for law and for socio-legal studies. For Rancière, equality is not a goal to be achieved (as history progresses), but rather a principle of emancipatory actions to be presupposed and highlighted. 6 6 “Rethinking the New World Order: responses to globalization/American hegemony,” in The History of Continental Philosophy, Vol. Communities of Sense argues for a new understanding of the relation between politics and aesthetics in today’s globalized and image-saturated world. Our contention is that not all forms of disagreement, disidentification and classificatory struggle signify active and progressive resistance to the neoliberal production of class names. Critical and Cultural Theory Symposium, Södertorn University, Stockholm, 2012. This article reports findings on class identities amongst a small sample of mainly working-class residents in the City of Salford.
Investors In Renewable Energy, How Much Will My Unemployment Tax Refund Be, Global Grant Application Form, Chinthavishtayaya Shyamala Dialogues, Airbus Scholarship Philippines, Wells Fargo Retirement Plan, Green Bonds Framework, Othello Betrayal Quotes, What Do You Call A Blind Gynecologist, Breaking Bad Andrea Death Episode,
Discussion ¬